Pep Boys vs Mavis: Repair, Brake, Tire and Battery Warranties Compared
Pep Boys and Mavis share an owner but not warranty terms. Pep Boys defaults to 90 days or 3,000 miles; Mavis lists 12 months or 12,000 miles on many parts, covers rotors and calipers, and gives batteries up to 48 months free replacement.

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.
Our pick
- See price at Pep Boys
Top pick
Pep Boys
US automotive service and parts chain selling tires, batteries and car maintenance.
Pep Boys and Mavis are now under the same roof. Mavis completed its purchase of Pep Boys on August 20, 2026, and Pep Boys kept its name. But the two chains still publish separate warranty terms, and they differ in ways that matter when a brake job, a set of tires or a battery goes wrong. This comparison sets Pep Boys' published warranties against Mavis's, using each company's own warranty pages, so you know what you are getting before you approve work at either one.

A note on dates: Mavis's terms are from its warranty page as of November 12, 2026. Pep Boys' terms are from its customer-care policies and tire-warranty pages as we last read them on October 30, 2026, and we could not recheck them for this article, so confirm current terms on your invoice.
The short version
| Pep Boys | Mavis | |
|---|---|---|
| Default repair warranty | 90 days or 3,000 miles on service and installed parts, unless the invoice says otherwise | 3 months or 3,000 miles for items not listed in its parts table |
| Most major repairs | Default applies unless the invoice lists longer terms | Many listed parts carry 12 months or 12,000 miles on both part and labor |
| Brake pads | Lifetime replacement pads; free installation for the period on the work order | Lifetime part warranty; labor 12 months or 12,000 miles |
| Rotors and calipers | Not covered by the lifetime pad warranty | 12 months or 12,000 miles, part and labor |
| Batteries | Interstate: 18 to 36 months free replacement, depending on line | 20 to 48 months free replacement, then prorated to month 60 |
| Tire defects | Free replacement for 90 days, then prorated | Prorated by wear for the usable life of the tire |
| Road hazard | Optional plan, until 2/32 inch of tread | Optional, the shorter of 3 years or 2/32 inch of tread |
Default repair warranty: almost the same
Both chains start from a similar baseline. Pep Boys says automotive service and installed parts are warranted for 90 days or 3,000 miles, whichever comes first, unless your invoice lists different terms. Mavis's catch-all is 3 months or 3,000 miles for parts and labor on "all other items not listed," excluding tires and batteries.
The difference is what sits above that floor. Mavis publishes a long table of specific parts with longer terms. Pep Boys points you to the Limited Warranties page of your invoice for anything beyond the default. In practice, at Pep Boys the invoice is where you find out whether a given repair carries more than 90 days.
Mavis's parts table
Mavis lists separate "part" and "labor" warranties for each item. A "12/12,000" warranty lasts 12 months or 12,000 miles, whichever comes first. Highlights from its table:
- 12 months or 12,000 miles, part and labor: water pumps, radiators and hoses, alternators and starters, power steering pumps, wheel bearings, tie rods, ball joints, control arms, axle shafts and most exhaust parts.
- Lifetime part warranty: brake pads, brake shoes, struts, shocks, air shocks and muffler assemblies, each with 12 months or 12,000 miles of labor.
- Catalytic converter: 60 months or 50,000 miles on the part, 12 months or 12,000 miles on labor.
- Shorter terms: wheel alignment, wiper blades, bulbs and A/C recharge at 3 months or 3,000 miles. TPMS sensors get 12/12,000 on the part but 3/3,000 on labor.
Mavis explains how "lifetime" works: you are always entitled to a free replacement part, but once the labor warranty has expired, you pay the current labor rate to have it fitted.

Brakes: the biggest practical difference
Both chains offer lifetime brake pads, and both come with conditions.
At Pep Boys, the brake service warranty replaces pads or shoes that wear out under normal, non-commercial passenger car use during the period written on your service work order, and installing them is free during that period. It does not cover other brake parts such as rotors or calipers, or the labor to restore the brake system. If those repairs are needed and you decline them, Pep Boys gives you uninstalled, non-warranted replacement pads instead. Our Pep Boys warranty guide covers those terms in detail.
At Mavis, brake pads and shoes carry a lifetime part warranty with 12 months or 12,000 miles of labor. Rotors, rebuilt calipers, drums, wheel cylinders, master cylinders and power boosters each carry 12 months or 12,000 miles on both part and labor. Brake lines get 12/12,000 on the part and 3/3,000 on labor.
Neither chain's lifetime pads add up to a free brake job. But Mavis's published table spells out longer coverage for rotors and calipers, while at Pep Boys those parts fall back to the default or to whatever your invoice lists.
Batteries
Pep Boys sells Interstate batteries, and the free replacement period depends on the line. When we checked, its buying guide listed 36 months for MTX, 30 months for MTP, 24 months for MT and 18 months for M. See our Pep Boys battery guide for prices and specs.
Mavis publishes its own battery table. AGM batteries get 48 months of free replacement, Sprinter Max 36 months, Sprinter and Marathon AUX Euro Fit 24 months, and Classic 20 months. After the free period, every battery moves to a prorated credit through month 60, and installation labor is covered for 12 months.

Mavis shows its proration formula: (60 minus the battery's month of life) divided by 60, times the original cost. Its example is a $200 battery that fails in month 35, which earns a credit of $83.33.
Tires
Pep Boys replaces a tire that proves defective in material or workmanship free of charge for the first 90 days. After that, it replaces or refunds with a prorated adjustment based on usable tread remaining. Its tread wear-out warranty covers the mileage shown on the work order, prorated by the miles you did not get, once tread reaches 2/32 inch.
Mavis has three tire warranties. Its New Tire Limited Warranty covers defects for as long as the tire has usable tread, which it defines as 2/32 inch or more. You pay a share of the original price equal to the percentage of wear, and installation of the replacement is free. Its Limited Mileage Warranty gives a pro-rata credit if a tire doesn't reach the mileage on your receipt. All three require what Mavis calls Proper Tire Care, including correct inflation and regular rotation, with every 5,000 miles recommended.
The trade-off: Pep Boys gives a fully free replacement in the first 90 days, while Mavis charges by wear from the start but keeps defect coverage running for the tire's life.

Road hazard protection
Neither chain's standard tire warranty covers nails, potholes or debris. Both sell optional coverage.
- Pep Boys' Road Hazard Protection Plan repairs a damaged tire free if possible, otherwise replaces it or gives a prorated refund, until the tire reaches 2/32 inch of tread. It is not transferable.
- Mavis's Road Hazard Limited Warranty, if purchased, covers cuts, snags, bruises, impact breaks and unrepairable punctures for the shorter of 3 years or until tread falls below 2/32 inch. The replacement price is prorated by wear. Tires that can safely be repaired are excluded.
Making a claim
Both chains tie warranties to the original buyer and to your paperwork.
- Pep Boys: your service work order and invoice, including the Limited Warranties page, set the terms. Keep them.
- Mavis: you need a legible physical or digital copy of your invoice and service record, plus the failed tire or part. Mavis says its warranties are honored at all locations owned by Mavis Tire Supply LLC, and its Consumer Solutions Team is at (800) 757-4291.
Mavis's warranty page does not say whether those terms now extend to Pep Boys stores, and the acquisition announcements say nothing about combining warranties. Until either company says otherwise, claim a Pep Boys warranty at Pep Boys and a Mavis warranty at Mavis. Our Pep Boys and Mavis acquisition FAQ covers what the deal does and doesn't change.
Which is better?
On published terms, Mavis's warranty is more generous for bigger repairs: 12 months or 12,000 miles on many parts, coverage on rotors and calipers, and longer free battery periods on its AGM line. Pep Boys is stronger on tire defects early on, with fully free replacement in the first 90 days. For anything else, the deciding factor is what your invoice says, so ask either shop to write the part and labor warranty next to each line before you approve the work.
References
- Mavis, Manufacturer, Tire, Parts and Battery Warranty Terms and Conditions: https://www.mavis.com/tire-parts-warranty/
- Mavis, Warranties overview: https://www.mavis.com/tire-warranty/
- Pep Boys, Customer Care: Policies (read October 30, 2026): https://www.pepboys.com/customer-care/policies
- Pep Boys, Road Hazard Protection Plan (read October 30, 2026): https://www.pepboys.com/tips-guides/tire-buying/tire-warranty
- Pep Boys, Car Battery Replacement: https://www.pepboys.com/batteries/battery-replacement
- Mavis Tire Express Services Corp. and Icahn Enterprises L.P., "Mavis Completes Acquisition of Pep Boys from Icahn Enterprises" (August 20, 2026), SEC exhibit 99.1: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/813762/000110465926099264/tm2623713d1_ex99-1.htm
Meet your guide
Lipeiguan
author