Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamonds at Zales: A Buyer's FAQ
Are Zales lab-grown diamonds real, certified and covered by the same warranty? Origin, grading, price, resale value and trade-in limits explained from Zales's official pages and FTC guidance.

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.
Our pick
- See price at Zales
Top pick
Zales
US jewelry retailer founded in Texas in 1924, part of Signet Jewelers, selling engagement rings, lab-grown and natural diamond jewelry, gold and silver jewelry...
What this guide covers
Lab-grown and natural diamonds are both real diamonds, and at Zales they come with the same warranty, the same trade-in eligibility and the same kind of independent grading report. The real differences are origin, price and how well the stone may hold its value, which Zales itself flags on its lab-grown diamond page.
This FAQ answers the questions buyers most often ask when choosing between the two at Zales, based on Zales's official lab-grown diamond page, its Lifetime Diamond Commitment terms and the US Federal Trade Commission's Jewelry Guides. It is research-based; we have not examined any stones in person.

Quick comparison
This table follows the side-by-side chart Zales publishes on its lab-grown diamond page (as shown on November 10, 2026).
| Lab-grown | Natural | |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Grown in a lab | Formed in the earth |
| Made of carbon | Yes | Yes |
| Age | Weeks to months | 1 to 3 billion years |
| Supply | Potentially unlimited | Finite and rare |
| Independently certified | Yes | Yes |
| Conflict-free | Yes, per Zales | Yes, per Zales |
| Lifetime Diamond Commitment | Included | Included |
| Trade-in eligible | Yes, for lab-grown only | Yes, for natural or lab-grown |
| Relative price | $$ | $$$ |
Is a lab-grown diamond a "real" diamond?
Yes. Zales states that lab-grown diamonds have the same optical, chemical and physical properties as natural diamonds. US regulators agree: when the FTC revised its Jewelry Guides in 2018, it removed the word "natural" from its definition of a diamond, because lab-created products with essentially the same optical, physical and chemical properties as mined diamonds are also diamonds.
What the FTC does require is disclosure. Sellers must make clear that a lab-grown stone is not mined, using terms such as "laboratory-grown," "laboratory-created" or a manufacturer-created qualifier. That is why Zales product names say "Lab-Grown Diamond" right in the title.
How is a lab-grown diamond made?
According to Zales, the process starts with a diamond seed, a thin sliver of carbon crystal. The seed is exposed to high temperatures and pressures with a carbon coating, which helps it crystallize and grow into a larger rough diamond. The whole process takes weeks to months, compared with the one to three billion years Zales cites for natural diamonds.
Can anyone tell them apart?
Not by looking. Zales says lab-grown and natural diamonds cannot be distinguished even with a professional 10x loupe. For that reason, Zales's lab-grown diamonds are inscribed with "lab-grown diamond" on the girdle, the thin outer edge of the stone. That inscription, together with the grading report, is how you or a future jeweler can confirm what you have.
Is one higher quality than the other?
Neither is better by default. Zales notes that both come in a full range of cut, color, clarity and carat weight, so a natural diamond can be lower grade than a lab-grown one and vice versa. Quality comes from the grading, not the origin.
Zales says its lab-grown diamonds are certified colorless with few to no inclusions visible to the naked eye. Many of its lab-grown product names include the grade in parentheses, such as "(F/VS2)" or "(F/SI2)," where the letter is the color grade and the second part is the clarity grade. On the color scale Zales shows, D to F is colorless, G to J near colorless, K to M faint, N to R very light and S to Z light.
Do lab-grown diamonds come with a certificate?
Yes. Zales says its lab-grown diamonds are graded to the same standards as its natural diamonds and come with an independent laboratory report covering the four Cs: cut, color, clarity and carat weight. Zales also notes that diamond total weights are approximate and points buyers to its 4Cs Diamond Guide and the variance chart in the details section of each diamond product page.
How much cheaper are lab-grown diamonds?
Zales does not publish a percentage. Its comparison chart simply marks lab-grown as "$$" and natural as "$$$," and it explains that because lab-grown diamonds can be produced in abundance, they cost less and make larger stones more affordable.
To give a sense of lab-grown pricing on the site, these were among the pieces on the Zales.com homepage on November 10, 2026:
| Lab-grown piece shown on Zales.com | Listed price (Nov 10, 2026) |
|---|---|
| 1/4 ct. t.w. solitaire earrings, sterling silver (F/SI2) | $100 |
| 1 ct. t.w. bezel-set station bracelet, sterling silver (F/VS2) | $299, listed down from $599 |
| 1/2 ct. t.w. marquise-cut five-stone band, 10K white gold (F/VS2) | $799 |
| 10 ct. t.w. certified tennis necklace, sterling silver (F/SI2) | $1,499, listed down from $2,999 |
| 5 ct. t.w. tennis necklace, 10K white gold (F/VS2) | $4,299 |
Prices change often, so check the product page before buying. Comparing lab-grown and natural pieces of the same design, metal and total weight on Zales.com is the most reliable way to see the gap for the exact item you want.

Will a lab-grown diamond hold its value?
This is the biggest practical difference, and Zales is direct about it. On its lab-grown page it says that because lab-grown diamonds can be produced in abundance, "their relative abundance may not ensure that the value will hold over time." In plain terms, if resale or long-term value matters to you, a lab-grown stone carries more uncertainty than a natural one.
Zales's own trade-in rules soften this a little, but only within Zales. Under the Lifetime Diamond Commitment, a Zales diamond with a valid receipt is credited at 100% of its original net purchase price toward a new diamond item that costs at least twice as much. The important limit: lab-grown diamonds can be traded in only for lab-grown diamonds, while natural diamonds can be traded for natural or lab-grown.
Do warranties and service plans differ?
No. Zales says it provides the same warranties and service plans for both. The Lifetime Diamond Commitment covers diamond rings, earrings, bracelets and necklaces bought new at Zales. If a diamond is chipped, broken or lost from its original setting in normal wear, Zales replaces it at no charge, and lab-grown diamonds are replaced with lab-grown diamonds. To keep that coverage, you must bring the piece in for cleaning and inspection every six months and keep your inspection record.
Our Zales shopping guide covers the commitment, protection plans, returns and Vault Rewards in more detail.
Can I return or exchange a lab-grown piece?
The same rules apply to both. Zales's Returns and Exchanges page allows jewelry returns within 30 days of the purchase or shipment date and exchanges within 60 days in a store. Custom designs, engraved or altered pieces and special orders are excluded. Some Zales pages, including the lab-grown page, still advertise "60-day returns," so rely on the dedicated policy page if you may want a refund.
Which should you choose?
Based on what Zales publishes, a simple way to decide:
- Choose lab-grown if you want the most size or the highest grade for your budget, you plan to keep the piece, and resale value is not a priority. Zales itself frames lab-grown as the way to "maximize your budget, typically offering more size for the same cost."
- Choose natural if rarity and the traditional origin matter to you, or if you think you may want to trade toward natural diamonds later, since lab-grown trade-ins stay within lab-grown.
- Either way, compare the grading report, not just the label, and confirm the color and clarity grades in the product name or report before you buy.
If you are shopping for the holidays, our Black Friday 2026 fashion and beauty buying guide has broader tips on timing purchases and keeping receipts.
References
- Lab-Grown Diamonds, Zales
- Lifetime Diamond Commitment, Zales
- Returns and Exchanges, Zales
- Zales homepage product listings
- Customer Help Center, Zales
- Guides for the Jewelry, Precious Metals, and Pewter Industries, Federal Register (FTC, Aug 16, 2018)
- FTC Attorney Answers Questions on Jewelry Guides, JCK
Meet your guide
Lipeiguan
author