Life is Good vs Old Navy: Graphic Tees, Prices, Shipping and Returns
A research-based comparison of Life is Good and Old Navy tees as of November 17, 2026: the $24.95 5.9 oz Crusher tee versus Old Navy's $19.99-$22.99 Vintage Crew-Neck and $26.99 graphic tees, plus official shipping, returns and Encore rules.

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.
Quick picks
- See price at Life is Good
Top pick
Life is Good
Life is Good is the original positive lifestyle apparel brand, founded in 1994 by brothers Bert and John Jacobs. It sells graphic and solid tees, hoodies, hats...
- See price at Old Navy
Also great
Old Navy
Gap Inc. apparel brand founded in 1994, selling clothing for women, men, kids, toddlers and babies, plus maternity, activewear and family pajamas, in more than...
Life is Good and Old Navy both sell casual cotton tees, including graphic styles, but they are not the same kind of store. Life is Good is a specialty lifestyle brand built around printed tees. Old Navy is a much larger apparel retailer, with tees sitting alongside jeans, jackets and kids' clothes. The useful comparison is specific: what the official product pages say about fabric and price, and what each brand's own policy pages say about shipping, returns and rewards, as of November 17, 2026. This is a research-based reading of those pages, not a wear test.

Two different kinds of tee brands
Life is Good's About us page says brothers Bert and John Jacobs spent years selling homemade t-shirt designs before designing their first Life is Good shirt in 1994. The same page says the company donates more than 10% of annual net profits to The Life is Good Playmaker Project, which supports kids in need. The catalog is concentrated on graphic and solid tees, hoodies, hats and related casual pieces sold at Lifeisgood.com.
Old Navy, by contrast, is a broad clothing retailer. Its site sells women's, men's, kids' and baby apparel, and the official Soft Vintage Tees shop page is only one slice of that assortment. That page is a fair place to compare everyday tees and graphic tees, because it lists both solid Vintage Crew-Neck styles and licensed graphic tees, with official prices and product details.
If you want a deeper look at Life is Good's tee fabrics and fits, see our Women's Solid Short Sleeve Crusher Tee review and the guide to choosing Crusher, Crusher-LITE, Boxy and Slim Fit tees. For Old Navy's membership, shipping and return rules in more detail, see the Old Navy shopping guide and our Old Navy review. The comparison below restates only the product and policy facts we re-checked on official pages on November 17, 2026.
Fabric and fit: Crusher vs Vintage
The clearest Life is Good reference tee is the Women's Solid Short Sleeve Crusher Tee. The official page lists it as a classic-fit, garment-washed jersey at 5.9 oz. Solid colors are 100% USA Grown Cotton; heather colors are 80% USA Grown Cotton / 20% polyester. The shirt has a slight waist shape, a cotton/spandex rib at the neck, and self-fabric taping from shoulder to shoulder. On November 17, 2026, in-stock sizes were listed at $24.95. The same product page's structured data listed a 4.8 rating from 1,063 reviews.
Life is Good also sells a lighter jersey. The Women's Solid Crusher-LITE Vee Tunic and the Men's Solid Short Sleeve Crusher-LITE Slim Fit Tee both list 100% cotton at 4.57 oz, described as a lightweight jersey in fine yarn for added drape, also garment washed. The women's solid short-sleeve page offers both Crusher and Crusher-LITE fabric options. Those details matter if you are comparing "a Life is Good tee" with a generic cotton tee: the brand publishes a fabric weight, a USA Grown Cotton claim on Crusher solids, and more than one official fit. Fit names and measuring steps are on the Fit Guide.
Old Navy's everyday comparison piece is the Vintage Crew-Neck T-Shirt. The official page calls it a soft jersey in 100% cotton, with a loose fit that hits below the waist, a rib-knit crew neck, short drop-shoulder sleeves and vented sides. It is imported, and the care line says to machine wash according to the care instruction label. On November 17, 2026, that colorway was listed at $19.99, with all displayed size offers in stock. Other Vintage Crew-Neck colorways on the same shop page were listed at $22.99, including product 897401 and product 1183788, which also lists soft jersey, 100% cotton, a loose fit and vented sides. The Vintage Crew-Neck product pages showed an aggregate rating of 4.75 from 29,016 ratings.

Old Navy does not publish an ounce weight on these Vintage Crew-Neck pages the way Life is Good does for Crusher and Crusher-LITE. What you can say from the official copy is 100% cotton jersey, a loose rather than classic fit, and a lower listed price than the $24.95 Crusher tee.
Graphic tees: optimism prints vs licensed vintage graphics
Life is Good's catalog is built around its own graphics as well as solids. The Crusher tee reviewed above is the solid reference, but the brand's hoodies, hats and tees use the same "Life is Good" voice across many printed designs. Old Navy's graphic tees, at least on the Soft Vintage Tees page, lean toward licensed or seasonal art.
Two in-stock examples from that page on November 17, 2026, were listed at $26.99. The Chevy Corvette Vintage Graphic T-Shirt for Women is described as a soft cotton t-shirt with a classic, straight and easy fit that hits at the hip, a crewneck, short sleeves, and an officially licensed Chevy Corvette vintage ad graphic at the front. The Vintage Apres Graphic T-Shirt is also described as a soft cotton t-shirt with a crewneck, short sleeves and a Vintage Apres graphic at the front. Both had in-stock sizes at $26.99. Those listed prices sit a little above the $24.95 Crusher tee and well above the $19.99-$22.99 Vintage Crew-Neck solids.

Old Navy also sells licensed sports graphics at higher listed prices. The Seattle Seahawks Vintage Oversized T-Shirt for Women, for example, was listed at $34.99 in a 100% cotton oversized fit that hits at the waist, with a rib-knit crew neck and elbow-length sleeves. That is a different shape and a higher listed price than either the Crusher tee or the $26.99 Corvette and Apres graphics.
The practical split is this: Life is Good is selling its own artwork on a mid-weight, garment-washed cotton jersey with a published 5.9 oz weight. Old Navy is selling a wider mix of solid vintage tees and licensed graphics, usually described only as 100% cotton or soft cotton, at listed prices that ran from the high teens for solid Vintage Crew-Necks to the mid-$20s and mid-$30s for graphics on the day we checked.
Shipping and returns
The policy gap is as clear as the price gap, and it is documented on each brand's own pages.
Life is Good's free shipping page says contiguous U.S. orders of $35.00 and up ship free, and that orders of $34.99 and under are charged a $4.95 shipping fee. Qualifying amounts are calculated after promotions and discounts and exclude donations, gift certificates and taxes. The shipping policy lists U.S. standard ground at $4.95 for 5-7 business days, two-day shipping at $14.95 and next-day shipping at $39.95, with expedited cutoffs at 12 pm ET. The company says it ships within the United States and Canada only. Made-to-order items are described as shipping from the U.S. factory within 2-3 business days.
On returns, Life is Good's Returns and Exchanges page offers a refund within 60 days of purchase if the merchandise is unused, unworn and in good condition. A $4.95 shipping fee is deducted from return refunds. Exchanges for a different size or color are free on U.S. orders. Orders placed between November 1 and December 31, 2026, can be returned or exchanged through February 28, 2027. Returns and exchanges are for U.S. orders only. Those rules are summarized in our Life is Good shopping guide.
Old Navy's offer is membership-based. The official Encore Membership page, re-read on November 17, 2026, lists three levels: Core (join for free, 5 points per $1 at the family of brands), Premier (unlock more perks after spending $350+ annually) and All-Access (Encore cardmembers). The same page lists free basic shipping on purchases of $50+ for Core, free standard shipping on purchases of $50+ for Premier, and free standard shipping on purchases of $35+ for All-Access. The site header also states free shipping on orders of $50+ for Encore members. Encore also lists free online returns, plus extended return windows of up to 45 days for Premier and up to 60 days for All-Access, with returns after 30 days receiving credit. Old Navy's Encore account is shared across Old Navy, Gap, Banana Republic and Athleta; that structure is also covered in our Old Navy vs Gap Factory comparison.
The short version: Life is Good publishes a simple $35 free-shipping threshold and a 60-day return window for U.S. shoppers, with a $4.95 fee on return refunds and free size or color exchanges. Old Navy's free shipping and longer return windows depend on Encore tier, with $50+ (or $35+ at All-Access) as the official free-shipping thresholds on the Encore page, and a 30-day baseline implied by the "returns after 30 days receive credit" language. Life is Good does not operate a comparable multi-brand membership.
Who should shop where
Choose Life is Good if you want the brand's own graphics, a published 5.9 oz Crusher fabric (or 4.57 oz Crusher-LITE), and a straightforward $35 free-shipping threshold with a 60-day U.S. return window. The listed $24.95 Crusher tee costs more than Old Navy's $19.99-$22.99 Vintage Crew-Neck, and Life is Good ships only to the United States and Canada.
Choose Old Navy if you want a lower listed price on a loose-fit 100% cotton vintage tee, a wide range of licensed graphic tees, and the Encore perks that come with a free membership or a card. The official Vintage Crew-Neck pages do not list a fabric weight, and the best shipping and return terms are tied to Encore status rather than offered the same way to every checkout.
Neither site's listed prices are guaranteed to stay put, and Old Navy in particular often shows different current prices by colorway. The figures in this article are the ones published on the official product and policy pages on November 17, 2026.
References
- Women's Solid Short Sleeve Crusher Tee — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Women's Solid Crusher-LITE Vee Tunic — Life is Good, Crusher-LITE 4.57 oz spec, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Men's Solid Short Sleeve Crusher-LITE Slim Fit Tee — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- About us — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- FREE SHIPPING on $35+ — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Shipping policy — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Returns and Exchanges — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Fit Guide — Life is Good, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Vintage Crew-Neck T-Shirt — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Vintage Crew-Neck T-Shirt — Old Navy, $22.99 colorway, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Vintage Crew-Neck T-Shirt — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Chevy Corvette Vintage Graphic T-Shirt for Women — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Vintage Apres Graphic T-Shirt — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Seattle Seahawks Vintage Oversized T-Shirt for Women — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Soft Vintage Tees — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Encore Membership Program — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
- Old Navy homepage — Old Navy, accessed November 17, 2026.
Meet your guide
Lipeiguan
author