Old Navy vs Gap Factory: Prices, Sales, Rewards and Returns Compared

Old Navy and Gap Factory share Encore rewards and nearly identical shipping and return rules, but differ in what they sell, list prices, how their sales work and where you can return items.

Old Navy vs Gap Factory: Prices, Sales, Rewards and Returns Compared

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.

Quick picks

  1. Top pick

    Old Navy

    Gap Inc. apparel brand founded in 1994, selling clothing for women, men, kids, toddlers and babies, plus maternity, activewear and family pajamas, in more than...

    See price at Old Navy
  2. Also great

    Gap Factory

    Gap Inc.'s outlet store selling Gap Factory clothing for women, men, kids and babies, with Encore rewards.

    See price at Gap Factory

Jump to the full guide

Old Navy and Gap Factory are Gap Inc.'s two value-focused stores, and they share more than a parent company. They use the same membership program, almost identical shipping tables and the same basic return rules. They aren't interchangeable, though. They sell different clothes at different list prices, they discount in different ways, and you can't return an item bought at one to the other. This comparison draws on both brands' websites and customer service pages as we read them on November 10, 2026, in the middle of both stores' early Black Friday events.

Screenshot of the Gap Factory homepage showing 40% Off Everything + Extra 10% Off, Extra 50% Off Clearance, 60% Off Early Black Friday Deals and Gift Picks from $5

At a glance

Old Navy Gap Factory
Owner Gap Inc. Gap Inc.
Website oldnavy.gap.com gapfactory.com
Main departments Women, Men, Girls, Boys, Toddler, Baby, Maternity, Activewear, Family Pajamas Women, Men, Girls, Boys, Toddler, Baby, Pajamas, Deals & Clearance
Own sub-brands Old Navy Sport, Old Navy Beauty Co. Gap labels such as GapFlex jeans
Rewards Encore Encore
New-card first-purchase offer (Nov 10) Extra 30% off Extra 20% off
Free shipping for members $50+ ($35+ for cardmembers with the card) $50+ ($35+ for cardmembers with the card)
Standard return window 30 days 30 days
Mail returns Free for Encore members, $6 for nonmembers Free for Encore members, $6 for nonmembers
Kids' defect guarantee Kid's Guarantee, up to 1 year Not listed in the return quick facts
Returns to the other brand Not accepted Not accepted

What each store sells

Old Navy is a family store first. Its navigation runs from baby and toddler sizes through to maternity and adult clothing, with a big Family Pajamas section for matching prints across ages. Its main in-house lines include SoComfy fleece, Wow jeans, SoSoft knits and EveryWear tees. It added an activewear sub-brand, Old Navy Sport, in September 2026, and Gap Inc. announced Old Navy Beauty Co. in August 2026. During the holiday season, Old Navy also sells licensed and designer collections, including an Old Navy x Disney range.

Gap Factory sells Gap-branded clothing, and its labels show it: GapFlex jeans, Soft Wear denim and Gap × Disney Mickey Mouse flannel pajama pants appeared on its listings on November 10. Its navigation is similar in shape: Women, Men, Girls, Boys, Toddler (6M–5Y), Baby (0–24M), Pajamas and a dedicated Deals & Clearance section. For how Gap Factory's clothes relate to the main Gap stores, see our Gap vs Gap Factory comparison.

Old Navy product image of a model in the red-and-white plaid Printed Flannel Pajama Pants Set for Women

Prices and how the sales work

Both stores lean heavily on discounts, but their list prices start at different levels. Here are sample listings from November 10, 2026. They aren't identical items, so treat this as an indication of price level, not a like-for-like test.

Store Item List price Price shown
Old Navy Mid-Rise Wow Boot-Cut Jeans (women's) $36.99 $22.19
Old Navy Flannel Pajama Set for Men (shirt and pants) $49.99 $29.99
Old Navy SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt $44.99 $22.49
Gap Factory Straight Jeans (men's) $59.99 $23.99
Gap Factory GapFlex Straight Jeans (men's) $69.99 $41.99
Gap Factory Relaxed Flannel PJ Pants (men's, pants only) $39.99 $23.99

Two patterns stand out. First, Gap Factory's list prices are higher, but its "Early Black Friday deal! Price as marked" items can fall to similar dollar prices. Men's Straight Jeans at $23.99 sit close to Old Navy's Wow jeans. Second, the structure of the events differs:

  • Old Navy's Friends & Family event (November 6–11, 2026) took 40% off everything for everyone and 50% off for shoppers paying with an Encore or Gap Inc. credit card. An extra 15% off was available only in the Old Navy app. Clearance, Today's Deals, gift cards and third-party items were excluded from the 40% offer. Our news report on the event has the full terms.
  • Gap Factory's homepage on the same day advertised "40% Off Everything + Extra 10% Off" applied at checkout, an extra 50% off clearance and 60% off early Black Friday deals. The fine print said exclusions apply. Some licensed items, such as the Peanuts and Disney pajama pants, were marked "Excluded from promotions."

If clearance is what you're after, Gap Factory was more generous on this date, with an extra 50% off. At Old Navy, clearance was excluded from the 40% offer, although the app-only 15% did include it. For one-stop family shopping during an event, Old Navy's flat 40% across almost everything is simpler.

Screenshot of Old Navy's homepage banner announcing the Friends & Family Event: 40% Off Everything, Ends 11/11, Exclusions apply

Rewards: one Encore account for both

Old Navy and Gap Factory both run on Encore, Gap Inc.'s shared membership. The same account works at Old Navy, Gap (including Gap Factory), Banana Republic and Athleta. Old Navy's Encore page lists three levels:

  • Core (free): 5 points per $1, free Basic shipping on $50+.
  • Premier ($350+ spent a year): free Standard shipping on $50+, returns up to 45 days and a 15% sale day once a year.
  • All-Access (Encore Credit Card): 25 points per $1 at the family of brands, free Standard shipping on $35+ with the card, returns up to 60 days and a 20% sale day.

Because spending is pooled, buying kids' basics at Old Navy and jeans at Gap Factory both count towards Premier status. The credit cards are brand-branded, though. Old Navy promotes the Old Navy Encore Credit Card with an extra 30% off your first purchase, while Gap Factory promotes an extra 20% off your first purchase with a new card. Both are subject to credit approval.

Shipping: practically identical

The two brands publish the same shipping table. Nonmembers pay $7.50 for Basic (5–8 business days) and $9.50 for Standard (2–5 business days). Core members get free Basic shipping over $50 and pay $7.50 for Standard. Premier and All-Access members get free Standard over $50, and cardmembers paying with the card get it from $35. Express (2–3 business days) is $18 and Priority (1–2 business days) is $25 at both, available only in the continental U.S.

There is one practical difference: because the stores are separate, you can't combine an Old Navy order and a Gap Factory order to reach the $50 threshold. Each cart has to qualify on its own.

Returns: same rules, separate counters

Both brands' Return Policy Quick Facts give a 30-day window from delivery (online) or purchase (in store). In-store returns are free for eligible purchases, mail returns are free for Encore members and nonmembers pay $6 to return by mail. Premier and All-Access members get 45 and 60 days, with returns after day 30 refunded as a Merchandise Return Card.

Screenshot of Old Navy's Return Policy Quick Facts listing free in-store returns, free mail returns for Encore Members, a $6 fee for nonmembers and a 30-day window

The rule that catches people out is in the Return Policy FAQ on Old Navy's site, which covers all of Gap Inc.'s brands: returns can only be made at the brand of purchase. An Old Navy sweater can't go back to a Gap Factory store, and a Gap Factory hoodie can't go back to Old Navy. If you live nearer one store than the other, factor that in.

Old Navy has one extra: the Kid's Guarantee. Girls and Boys clothing and shoes with a manufacturing defect, such as holes, rips, excessive shrinkage or broken zippers, can be returned for a refund for up to a year in Old Navy or Old Navy Outlet stores. Gap Factory's quick facts don't list an equivalent.

Old Navy's holiday return extension also applies to purchases made between October 15 and December 24, which can be returned through January 15. Check Gap Factory's own FAQ for its holiday terms before relying on the same dates there.

Which should you choose?

Choose Old Navy if:

  • You're dressing a whole family, especially babies, toddlers and kids. The Kid's Guarantee is a real advantage.
  • You want matching family pajamas or maternity clothing.
  • You like simple event pricing, such as 40% off almost everything with no clearance digging.
  • You'll use the app, since Old Navy runs app-only extras.

Choose Gap Factory if:

  • You want Gap-branded basics like GapFlex jeans at outlet prices.
  • You're a clearance hunter. Gap Factory's extra 50% off clearance was the deeper discount on November 10.
  • You prefer Gap's fits and styling and don't mind higher list prices before discounts.

Either way: join Encore before checking out, keep each cart above $50 on its own and remember that returns stay with the brand you bought from. For Old Navy's full rules, see our Old Navy shopping guide and Old Navy review. For Gap Factory, see our Gap Factory shopping guide.

References

  1. Old Navy. Homepage, oldnavy.gap.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://oldnavy.gap.com/
  2. Old Navy. "40% Off Everything" offer details, accessed November 10, 2026. https://oldnavy.gap.com/Asset_Archive/AllBrands/promoAPI/promo_lookup_details.html?promoId=1199753
  3. Gap Factory. Homepage, gapfactory.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://www.gapfactory.com/
  4. Gap Factory. "Shipping and Handling." gapfactory.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://www.gapfactory.com/customerService/info.do?cid=1192799
  5. Gap Factory. "Return or Exchange." gapfactory.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://www.gapfactory.com/customerService/info.do?cid=1037494
  6. Old Navy. "Shipping and Handling." oldnavy.gap.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://oldnavy.gap.com/customerService/info.do?cid=82725&cs=shipping_and_handling
  7. Old Navy. "Return Policy FAQ." oldnavy.gap.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://oldnavy.gap.com/customerService/info.do?cid=82724&cs=return_policy_faq
  8. Old Navy. "Encore Membership Program." oldnavy.gap.com, accessed November 10, 2026. https://oldnavy.gap.com/browse/info.do?cid=1095422
  9. Gap Inc. "Introducing Old Navy Sport." Press release, September 15, 2026. https://www.gapinc.com/en-us/articles/2026/09/introducing-old-navy-sport

Meet your guide

Lipeiguan

author