Lowe's vs Menards: Returns, Price Adjustments, Rebates and Rewards Compared

Lowe's and Menards both start at 90-day returns, but Menards gives appliances and gas equipment far longer while Lowe's offers price adjustments and same-day delivery. We compare returns, price drops, the 11% rebate, MyLowe's Rewards, store cards and delivery.

Lowe's vs Menards: Returns, Price Adjustments, Rebates and Rewards Compared

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.

Quick picks

  1. Top pick

    Lowe's

    FORTUNE 100 home improvement company based in Mooresville, North Carolina, operating more than 1,750 home improvement stores plus Lowes.com, with Pro, online an...

    See price at Lowe's
  2. Also great

    Menards

    Midwest US home improvement chain selling building materials, tools, hardware and garden supplies.

    See price at Menards

Jump to the full guide

If you live in the Midwest, Lowe's and Menards may both be a short drive away, and they stock much of the same lumber, paint, tools and appliances. Where they really differ is in how they treat you after the sale: how long you have to return a refrigerator or a gas generator, what happens when a price drops, and whether your savings come as a lower price today or as store credit later. This comparison lines up the two stores' published policies so you can pick the better store for a given purchase.

Lowe's policies come from its return policy page as we read it on November 13, 2026, and its rewards and shipping pages as we read them on October 31, 2026. Menards' policies come from its Help Center, rebate terms and BIG Card page as we read them on November 11, 2026. This is a research-based comparison of published terms, not a record of test purchases, and both retailers change their policies, so check the live page before a big order.

Lowe's store exterior with the Lowe's sign above the entrance

The short version

Lowe's Menards
Most returns with a receipt 90 days 90 days to original payment; after that, in-store credit
Major appliances 48 hours; 30 days if still factory-sealed 90 days if unused and in the original package; 7 days for a manufacturing defect
Gas generators and pressure washers 48 hours 30 days if unused, in the package and never filled with gas
Lost receipt Not accepted, but Lowe's can look the purchase up In-store credit at the lowest price, with ID
Special orders 20% restocking fee after 72 hours At Menards' discretion, 25% restocking fee
Price drops after you buy Price adjustment review by chat or phone Sale price adjustment within 14 days, paid as store credit
Signature savings Sale prices and the free MyLowe's Rewards program 11% mail-in rebates paid as store credit
Store card 365-day returns on Lowe's credit cards and accounts BIG Card: 2% rebate in merchandise certificates or special financing
ACSI in-store score (2026) 81 81

Returns: Menards gives big-ticket buyers more time

Both stores start from 90 days for most new, unused items with a receipt. Lowe's refunds to your original payment method in most cases. Menards refunds cash purchases in cash and card purchases to the card within 90 days, and after 90 days it still takes the item back but gives in-store credit for the original price.

The difference shows up in the exceptions.

  • Major appliances. Lowe's puts major appliances in its 48-hour group, counted from delivery or pickup. Its policy does allow items in original, unopened, undamaged, factory-sealed packaging to come back within 30 days. Menards allows a major appliance back within 90 days if it hasn't been used and is still in the original package, or within 7 days if it has a manufacturing defect. If you might change your mind about a washer or range before you unbox it, Menards gives you three times as long.
  • Gas-powered equipment. Lowe's lists portable generators, pressure washers, chainsaws and pole saws at 48 hours, and says the gas-powered versions don't get the 30-day sealed-box extension. Most other outdoor power equipment at Lowe's gets 30 days, and CRAFTSMAN battery and electric outdoor power equipment gets 90. Menards groups mowers, snowthrowers, tillers, log splitters, chipper shredders, generators and pressure washers together: 30 days, unused, in the original package and never filled with gas. For a generator or pressure washer, that's 30 days at Menards against 48 hours at Lowe's.
  • Other short windows at Lowe's. Air conditioners and evaporative coolers, paint sprayers, tile saws and "construction heat and parts" are also 48-hour items. TVs and electronics, liquid paint, water heaters, HVAC systems and most marketplace items get 30 days.
  • Plants. Lowe's gives trees, shrubs and perennials 365 days with a receipt; other plants get 30 days.
  • Holiday items. At Lowe's, Christmas and Halloween items must be returned on or before the holiday, and anything bought after the holiday is final sale.
  • Clearance and outlet. Menards' bargain area and clearance merchandise is final sale. Lowe's Outlet locations sell most items as final sale too, and eligible returns must go back to the same outlet.

Screenshot of Menards' return policy section, Returns with a Receipt within 90 Days of Purchase

Lost receipts and refund timing

Lowe's says it doesn't accept returns without a valid proof of purchase, but it can try to find your purchase using a receipt, order number, the payment card or digital wallet you used, your phone number or your MyLowe's Rewards account, and its refund verification may ask for a photo ID. Card refunds can take up to 7 business days to appear. Menards can print a return receipt at its kiosk or from your online account if you paid by card or check; without one, it may give in-store credit at the lowest price offered and requires a driver's license or state ID.

Special orders

Lowe's charges a 20% restocking fee on Special Order configured products returned or canceled more than 72 hours after purchase, and they must go back to the store where you bought them. Menards may accept special-order returns at its sole discretion with a 25% restocking fee, and it won't take back custom items such as doors, custom windows and custom countertops.

Price drops and price matching

Lowe's return policy FAQ says that if you find a lower price after your purchase, you can contact it by chat or call 1-877-465-6937, and it will review your purchase and the lower price to decide whether you qualify for a price adjustment. Its Lowest Price Guarantee counts the item price plus shipping or delivery cost, requires that the competitor can ship to your location, and is honored only for the customer who made the purchase.

Menards' Pricing FAQ describes a narrower tool: a sale price adjustment if you bought an item within 14 days before a sale started and it's in the current flyer. You bring the original receipt to a store during the sale, and the difference comes as a Menards Merchandise Credit Check that can't be used on Menards.com. End-of-season discounts, closeouts and promotions such as the 11% Rebate, Bag Sale and Dutch Auction don't qualify. Items bought at full price within 14 days before an 11% sale can instead get an 11% price adjustment rebate by mail.

In practice, Lowe's offers a route to money back on your original purchase, while Menards' adjustment always arrives as store credit.

Savings: sale prices vs the 11% rebate

Menards' best-known promotion is its "11% Rebate on Everything" event. The rebate isn't an instant discount: you pay the full price, mail in the rebate receipt and form within one year of purchase, and Menards says to allow 6 to 8 weeks for processing. The Rebate Credit Check works only for future in-store purchases, not on Menards.com. In December 2025, Ohio's attorney general announced a $4.25 million settlement between Menards and 10 states over ads that the states said made rebates look like instant price cuts. Our Menards 11% rebate guide walks through the process.

Screenshot of the Menards Rebate Center: print and mail your rebates, or track your rebates

Lowe's savings work like ordinary retail discounts: the sale price is what you pay at the register. On top of that, MyLowe's Rewards is free to join. According to Lowe's program page as we read it on October 31, 500 points convert to $5 in MyLowe's Money, points expire 12 months after your last earning activity, and up to five MyLowe's Money rewards can be used per transaction. The bigger perk is delivery: rewards members get free same-day delivery on orders of $25 or more, for items up to 60 pounds each and 300 pounds in total, when they order by 2 p.m. and live within 20 miles of a participating store.

So which saves more? An 11% Menards rebate is worth a little less than 11% off, because you wait for it and can only spend it at a Menards store. If you shop at Menards several times a year, the gap is small. If you rarely go, a straightforward Lowe's sale price is easier to value.

Store credit cards

  • Lowe's extends returns to 365 days for purchases on the Lowe's Commercial Account, MyLowe's Pro Rewards Credit Card, MyLowe's Pro Rewards American Express Card, MyLowe's Rewards Credit Card and Lowe's Business Rewards. Purchases made with Lowe's Pay financing don't qualify for that extension. The longer window doesn't override the 48-hour and 30-day exceptions.
  • Menards' BIG Card has no annual fee. On each qualifying purchase you choose between a 2% everyday rebate in Menards merchandise certificates and special financing, and the 2% isn't earned on purchases that use promotional financing. Our BIG Card vs Contractor Card comparison covers Menards' other accounts.

Screenshot of the Menards BIG Card page offering a 2% rebate every day or special 6, 12 and 48-month financing

Pickup and delivery

Lowe's offers free standard shipping on orders of $25 or more that weigh under 150 pounds, to the contiguous U.S., with standard delivery typically arriving 1 to 4 business days after processing, plus the same-day perk for rewards members described above.

Menards has two pickup styles. "Menards Picks" orders are pulled for you for a nonrefundable processing fee and held for up to 14 days; "Customer Picks" is free, but you pull the items yourself. Same-day and next-day delivery is offered for select items in select areas: orders processed by 2:29 p.m. arrive the same day, and orders placed after that and before 5:00 p.m. come the next day. Large packages travel by freight carrier in a scheduled four-hour window, usually curbside.

Customer satisfaction

The American Customer Satisfaction Index's 2026 specialty retail results put Lowe's and Menards level at 81 out of 100 for in-store shopping, tied with The Home Depot. Lowe's rose from 79 the year before, while Menards fell from 83. The ACSI scored Lowe's online experience separately at 74, down from 76.

Lowe's customer service associate in a red vest helping a customer at the service desk

Which store should you use?

  • Buying a major appliance, generator or pressure washer: Menards' return windows are much longer, as long as you keep the item unused and in its packaging.
  • Worried about a price drop: Lowe's price adjustment review can put money back on your original purchase; Menards' 14-day sale adjustment pays in store credit.
  • Shopping Menards regularly: the 11% rebate events and the BIG Card's 2% certificates add up if you'll spend them.
  • Need small items today: Lowe's free same-day delivery for rewards members is hard to beat.
  • Buying special-order or custom products: Lowe's 20% fee after 72 hours is lower than Menards' 25%, and Menards may refuse custom items entirely.

For more detail on each store, see our Lowe's returns and MyLowe's Rewards guide, our Lowe's review, our Menards shopping guide and our comparisons of Lowe's vs Home Depot returns and Menards vs Home Depot.

References

  1. Lowe's, "Returns, Refunds & Exchanges at Lowe's." https://www.lowes.com/l/help/returns-policy (accessed November 13, 2026).
  2. Lowe's, "MyLowe's Rewards." https://www.lowes.com/l/about/mylowes-rewards (accessed October 31, 2026).
  3. Lowe's, "Free Shipping." https://www.lowes.com/l/help/free-shipping (accessed October 31, 2026).
  4. Menards, "Returns & Exchanges" (Help Center). https://www.menards.com/main/help-center/returns-exchanges/c-19282.htm (accessed November 11, 2026).
  5. Menards, "Pricing & Payment FAQs." https://www.menards.com/main/help-center/pricing-payments/c-19285.htm (accessed November 11, 2026).
  6. Menards, "Orders & Shipping FAQs." https://www.menards.com/main/help-center/orders-shipping/c-19280.htm (accessed November 11, 2026).
  7. Menards, "Menards BIG Card." https://www.menards.com/main/menards-credit-programs/menards-big-card/c-14304.htm (accessed November 11, 2026).
  8. Ohio Attorney General, "Ohio, 9 Other States Reach $4.25 Million Settlement With Menards Over Rebate Advertising," December 18, 2025.
  9. American Customer Satisfaction Index, "Specialty Retailers." https://theacsi.com/industries/retail/specialty-retailers/ (accessed November 11, 2026).
  10. American Customer Satisfaction Index, "ACSI Retail and Consumer Shipping Study 2025-2026." https://theacsi.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/26jan_Retail-Shipping-Study-Final.pdf

Meet your guide

Lipeiguan

author