New Era 9FORTY vs '47 Clean Up: Which Adjustable Team Cap Should You Buy?

New Era's structured 9FORTY and '47's relaxed Clean Up compared on construction, closures, materials, Yankees prices on each brand's store, and shipping and return rules, using official product pages and policies.

New Era 9FORTY vs '47 Clean Up: Which Adjustable Team Cap Should You Buy?

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.

Our pick

  1. Top pick

    New Era

    Buffalo, New York headwear maker founded in 1920 and the official on-field cap of Major League Baseball.

    See price at New Era

Jump to the full guide

If you want an adjustable team cap rather than a fitted one, two names come up more than any others: New Era's 9FORTY and '47's Clean Up. Both cost well under $50, both come in almost every MLB, NFL, NBA and NHL team, and both fit a wide range of heads without you needing to know your hat size. They come from different traditions, too: New Era is the long-time on-field cap maker, while '47 says it started in 1947 with a souvenir cart outside Fenway Park. And they are not the same cap. One is structured and keeps its shape; the other is soft and slouchy by design. This comparison uses each brand's own product pages, silhouette descriptions and store policies, checked on November 5, 2026, to show where they differ and which one suits which buyer.

This is a research-based comparison. We did not wear or test the caps; every spec and price below comes from the brands' official pages, and prices on team caps change often with sales and new releases.

New Era New York Yankees Navy Wordmark 9FORTY Adjustable Hat in navy with a chainstitch New York wordmark, shown from the front left

The short answer

  • Choose the New Era 9FORTY if you want a cap that holds a crisp, structured shape out of the box, with a pre-curved visor and the look of the caps sold at the ballpark. It is also the better pick if you like New Era's on-field styling and want something that matches a 59FIFTY you already own.
  • Choose the '47 Clean Up if you want a relaxed, broken-in "dad hat" feel from day one, a lower and softer crown, and a strap that sits flat at the back. It is the more casual option and, on the brands' own stores, the base version is usually the cheaper of the two.

The rest of this article explains why.

Construction: structured vs relaxed

The biggest difference is the crown.

New Era describes the 9FORTY as a cap that "combines a classic structured build and pre-curved visor with a comfortable, adjustable fit designed for everyday wear." On its 9FORTY silhouette page it lists the key features as front panel structure "for stability and classic cap shape," a full curved visor that is "ready to wear, no 'break-in' needed," and a contoured crown with "a rounded profile creating a streamlined look from front to back." In practice that means the front panels stand up on their own and the logo sits on a firm, upright face.

'47 takes the opposite approach. Its product description calls the Clean Up "a relaxed and curved adjustable strapback." The standard New York Yankees Cooperstown Clean Up is made from garment-washed cotton twill and is listed with a relaxed fit, a self-fabric strap, a raised embroidery logo on the front and a loop label on the back. There is no front structure, so the crown folds down and shapes itself to your head. The garment washing is what gives it a faded, worn-in look even when it is new.

Front view of the '47 New York Yankees Cooperstown Clean Up in washed navy cotton twill with a white raised-embroidery NY logo and a small '47 logo on the side

Closures and fit

Both caps are one-size adjustables, but they close differently.

  • New Era 9FORTY: depending on the style, New Era uses either a D-ring fabric strap or a snapback. The New York Yankees Navy Wordmark 9FORTY Adjustable and the League Essential Chestnut 9FORTY Adjustable both list "an adjustable D-Ring closure at the rear," while corduroy and A-Frame versions such as the Stone Corduroy 9FORTY A-Frame use a snapback.
  • '47 Clean Up: the standard Clean Up uses a self-fabric strap, the same cotton twill as the cap, finished with a buckle. Because the strap is cloth, it lies flat and is less noticeable from behind than a plastic snap.

Back of the New Era New York Yankees Navy Wordmark 9FORTY showing the fabric strap and D-ring closure

Back of the '47 New York Yankees Cooperstown Clean Up showing the self-fabric strap with a metal buckle

New Era's silhouette guide also explains that the 9FORTY is a family rather than a single cap. The Original 9FORTY is the everyday version. The A-Frame is a five-panel design with a pinched front "to accommodate larger logos." The M-Crown has six panels with medium depth and a shorter, slightly pre-curved visor. The Trucker adds mesh back panels for breathability, the M-Crown A-Frame combines the pinched front with a medium crown, and the Stretch Snap has a contoured, low-profile crown with a stretch sweatband. If you like the idea of a 9FORTY but want a lower or deeper fit, one of those variants is the place to look.

'47's lineup works the same way, with the Clean Up as its relaxed core shape and other models for buyers who want structure. For example, the '47 MVP is described as having "a structured crown, a curved visor, and an adjustable hook and loop closure" in a wool blend. So if you like '47's logos but want a cap that stands up more like a 9FORTY, the MVP is the closer match within that brand.

Materials

New Era's 9FORTY fabrics vary by release. The pieces we checked included a "soft fabrication" for the Navy Wordmark cap, corduroy for the Stone Corduroy A-Frame, and standard embroidered team logos on the League Essential line. The 9FORTY silhouette page also highlights an "elite material," which it calls "the fabric worn by the pros featuring engineered performance material," on versions built for that purpose.

The standard '47 Clean Up is cotton twill that has been garment washed. '47 also sells seasonal versions in other fabrics. Its New York Yankees Chain Stitch '47 Clean Up, for instance, is listed as 50/50 wool with a raised chain-stitch logo, still in the relaxed Clean Up shape.

In short, the basic Clean Up is simple washed cotton, while the 9FORTY's fabric depends on the release.

New Era New York Yankees League Essential Chestnut 9FORTY Adjustable Hat in brown with a tonal embroidered NY logo

Price on each brand's own store

These are the prices shown on each brand's US store for New York Yankees versions on November 5, 2026. Team, fabric and collection all change the price, so treat them as examples, not fixed list prices.

Cap Store price (Nov 5, 2026) Closure Shape
New Era Yankees League Essential Chestnut 9FORTY Adjustable $35.99 D-ring strap Structured, pre-curved visor
New Era Yankees Navy Wordmark 9FORTY Adjustable $38.99 D-ring strap Structured, pre-curved visor
New Era Yankees Stone Corduroy 9FORTY A-Frame Snapback $38.99 Snapback Structured five-panel A-Frame
'47 Yankees Cooperstown Clean Up (navy) $35.00 Self-fabric strap Relaxed, unstructured
'47 Yankees Chain Stitch Clean Up (wool blend) $40.00 Self-fabric strap Relaxed, unstructured
'47 Yankees MVP (black) $27.20 (marked down from $32.00) Hook and loop Structured

For comparison, New Era's New York Yankees Authentic Collection 59FIFTY fitted cap was $49.99 on the same day, so both adjustables sit well below the on-field fitted.

Shipping and returns when you buy direct

The caps are close in price, so the store rules can matter as much as the cap.

New Era (neweracap.com):

  • Standard ground shipping is free on pre-tax orders over $100 and costs $8 on orders of $99.99 or less. Expedited ground is $15 and express air is $25.
  • Orders do not ship the same day. New Era says most orders ship within 3 to 5 business days, and the delivery estimate starts after that processing time.
  • You have 30 days from the purchase date to request a return. Items must be unworn, unwashed and in new condition with all tags and stickers. Sale items, gift cards and custom pieces are among the exclusions, and the policy restricts returns on event-related products.
  • New Era does not offer exchanges, so changing a size or color means returning the item and placing a new order.

'47 (47brand.com):

  • The site banner on November 5, 2026 read "Free Shipping On All Orders."
  • '47 accepts returns and exchanges on items ordered from 47brand.com within 60 days of the delivery date. Items must be unworn, unwashed, and have all tags and stickers intact.
  • Refunds go back to the original payment method less a $7.00 shipping and restocking fee per initiated return, and original shipping is not refunded.
  • Free exchanges are only for the exact same item, or the same item in a different size at the same price, through '47's return and exchange system.
  • '47 says it cannot cancel or change orders once placed, so check the team and color before you check out.

If you are buying a single cap, '47's free shipping and longer return window are an advantage on paper. If you are buying several New Era caps and cross $100, New Era's shipping becomes free as well, and its returns have no restocking fee, but you get 30 days instead of 60.

'47 New York Yankees '47 MVP in black with a tonal raised NY logo and a structured crown

Which one should you buy?

Buy a New Era 9FORTY if:

  • You want a structured cap that looks the same every time you put it on.
  • You want a pre-curved visor with no break-in.
  • You prefer a snapback or D-ring closure, or you want a specific variant such as the A-Frame for a big front logo, the Trucker for mesh, or the M-Crown for a shorter visor.
  • You are building a collection around New Era's other silhouettes, such as the 59FIFTY.

Buy a '47 Clean Up if:

  • You want a soft, lived-in dad hat with a lower profile.
  • You like the faded look of garment-washed cotton.
  • You want a cloth strap that disappears at the back.
  • You are buying one cap and want free shipping and a 60-day return window.

Consider the '47 MVP if you like '47's designs but want a structured cap closer in feel to a 9FORTY.

Before you wear it

Both stores only accept returns on caps that are unworn and unwashed, with tags and stickers intact, so try a new cap on indoors and decide before you wear it out or clean it. Once it is yours, gentle care keeps either cap looking right for longer. For cleaning methods that protect the crown and visor, see our New Era cap care guide.

More on New Era

Bottom line

The 9FORTY and the Clean Up solve the same problem, an adjustable team cap that fits almost anyone, in opposite ways. New Era's 9FORTY is structured, pre-curved and sharp, with several variants if you want a different depth or front. '47's Clean Up is relaxed, washed and soft, with a cloth strap and an easier return policy on single orders. Pick the shape you will actually wear, then compare the price for your team on the day you buy.

References

  1. New Era Cap. "Silhouette Guide: 9FORTY." https://www.neweracap.com/pages/silhouette-guide-9forty (accessed November 5, 2026).
  2. New Era Cap. "New York Yankees Navy Wordmark 9FORTY Adjustable Hat." https://www.neweracap.com/products/new-york-yankees-navy-wordmark-9forty-adjustable (accessed November 5, 2026).
  3. New Era Cap. "New York Yankees League Essential Chestnut 9FORTY Adjustable Hat." https://www.neweracap.com/products/new-york-yankees-league-essential-chestnut-9forty-adjustable (accessed November 5, 2026).
  4. New Era Cap. "New York Yankees Stone Corduroy 9FORTY A-Frame Snapback Hat." https://www.neweracap.com/products/new-york-yankees-stone-corduroy-9forty-a-frame-snapback (accessed November 5, 2026).
  5. New Era Cap. "New York Yankees Authentic Collection 59FIFTY Fitted Hat." https://www.neweracap.com/products/new-york-yankees-authentic-collection-59fifty-fitted (accessed November 5, 2026).
  6. New Era Cap. "Shipping Policy." https://www.neweracap.com/policies/shipping-policy (accessed November 5, 2026).
  7. New Era Cap. "Refund Policy" (last updated July 15, 2026). https://www.neweracap.com/policies/refund-policy (accessed November 5, 2026).
  8. '47. "New York Yankees Cooperstown '47 Clean Up." https://www.47brand.com/products/new-york-yankees-47-clean-up (accessed November 5, 2026).
  9. '47. "New York Yankees Chain Stitch '47 Clean Up." https://www.47brand.com/products/new-york-yankees-chain-stitch-47-clean-up (accessed November 5, 2026).
  10. '47. "New York Yankees '47 MVP." https://www.47brand.com/products/new-york-yankees-47-mvp (accessed November 5, 2026).
  11. '47. "Refund Policy: Returns & Exchanges." https://www.47brand.com/policies/refund-policy (accessed November 5, 2026).
  12. '47. "Our Story." https://www.47brand.com/pages/our-story (accessed November 5, 2026).

Meet your guide

Lipeiguan

author