What USDA Certified Tender Means: Omaha Steaks' Tender and Very Tender Steaks Explained
USDA Certified Tender is a tenderness designation based on slice shear force testing, not a quality grade like Prime or Choice. Here is which Omaha Steaks cuts carry Tender or Very Tender, how the company says it qualifies, and what the label doesn't tell you.

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.
Our pick
- See price at Omaha Steaks
Top pick
Omaha Steaks
Nebraska-based seller of frozen steaks, meats, meals and food gift boxes shipped to US homes.
What this guide covers
Omaha Steaks puts a USDA shield reading "Certified Tender" or "Certified Very Tender" on many of its steaks. The label is easy to confuse with the USDA grades most shoppers know, Prime, Choice and Select, but it measures something different. This buyer's FAQ explains what the designation means, which Omaha Steaks cuts carry it, how the company says it qualifies, and what the label does and doesn't tell you before you order.
The details come from the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Agricultural Marketing Service (AMS) and from Omaha Steaks' own announcements in September 2024, August 2025 and April 2026.

What does "USDA Certified Tender" mean?
The AMS describes USDA Certified Tender or Very Tender as "a marketing program that aids consumers in making decisions on which beef cuts to purchase, and allows beef processors to market products as USDA Certified Tender or Very Tender." To qualify, a wholesaler or retailer must have certain beef muscles pass a slice shear force test, a mechanical test that measures how much force it takes to cut through a standard slice of cooked meat. Less force means a more tender cut.
There are two levels:
- USDA Certified Tender: the cut passed the tenderness threshold.
- USDA Certified Very Tender: a stricter level. Omaha Steaks describes it as "reserved for only the most exceptionally tender cuts".
Omaha Steaks' 2024 announcement quoted the USDA's view that tenderness is one of the most significant factors in whether consumers are happy with a beef cut. It added that the USDA worked with academia and industry over several years to build an objective tenderness scale, so that cuts with the label consistently meet expectations.
How is that different from Prime, Choice and Select?
USDA quality grades are mainly about marbling, the fat running through the lean meat. The AMS explains that Prime has at least slightly abundant marbling, Choice at least a small amount and Select at least a slight amount. It describes Select as "fairly tender" but notes that, with less marbling, it may lack some of the juiciness and flavor of the higher grades.
Certified Tender measures tenderness directly through the shear force test. The two systems answer different questions:
| USDA quality grade | USDA Certified Tender / Very Tender | |
|---|---|---|
| What it looks at | Marbling and maturity | Measured tenderness |
| How it's decided | Grading of the carcass | Slice shear force testing of specific muscles |
| What it suggests | Likely juiciness and flavor | How easily the steak cuts and chews |
| Who can use it | Graded beef | Processors whose cuts pass the test |
A steak can carry a quality grade and a tenderness designation at the same time, or only one of them. If you care most about flavor from fat, look at the grade. If you mainly want a steak that is easy to cut and chew, the tenderness label tells you more.
Which Omaha Steaks cuts are certified?
Omaha Steaks has announced the designations in stages:
- September 2024: its Filet Mignons earned USDA Certified Tender status. At the time, CEO Nate Rempe said Omaha Steaks was "one of only two beef processors in the entire country" to achieve the designation.
- August 2025: five more steak types earned USDA Certified Tender: Ribeyes, New York Strips, Top Sirloins, T-Bones and Porterhouse steaks. The Filet Mignons moved up to USDA Certified Very Tender, which the company says covers all its filet mignons, including the Butcher's Cut filets and bacon-wrapped filets.
- April 2026: Omaha Steaks introduced a Top Sirloin Filet designated USDA Certified Tender. The company says it is the only steak of its kind to be scientifically tested and given that designation.

How does Omaha Steaks say it qualifies?
According to its 2025 announcement, Omaha Steaks selects cuts, ages them "for an extended period", runs internal quality checks and then sends steaks for third-party shear-force testing at a USDA-certified lab before getting USDA approval. For the filet mignons, its 2024 announcement added that butchers trim exterior fat to give a leaner, steakhouse-style steak.
For the Top Sirloin Filet, the company describes a different route: a multi-year development process, aging for at least 35 days, and then a proprietary freezing process that it says locks in flavor and tenderness. The steaks are carved tall and thick like a filet mignon and double-trimmed for leanness.
Is the Top Sirloin Filet a cheaper filet mignon?
That is how Omaha Steaks positions it. The company says the Top Sirloin Filet delivers "a premium filet mignon experience at a non-premium price" and is similar in tenderness to a typical grocery store filet mignon, "all at the price of a sirloin". It comes in individually sealed portions:
- 5 oz. (31 g protein)
- 6 oz. (37 g protein)
- 7 oz. (46 g protein)
There is one useful distinction. The filet mignons carry the higher Very Tender designation, and the Top Sirloin Filet carries Certified Tender. If maximum tenderness is the goal, the filet is still the top tier. If you want a lean, tender steak at a lower price point, the Top Sirloin Filet is the cut Omaha Steaks built for that job. Check current prices on omahasteaks.com, because package contents and offers change often.
What the label doesn't tell you
- Flavor and juiciness. Tenderness is one factor. Marbling, aging and cooking all affect how a steak tastes.
- How you cook it. A certified-tender steak can still turn tough if it is overcooked. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service lists 145°F, measured with a food thermometer, followed by a rest of at least 3 minutes as the safe minimum for beef steaks. You can cook to a higher temperature if you prefer, but use a thermometer rather than guessing, because a tender cut gives you less margin once it goes past your preferred doneness.
- Every cut in the box. The designation applies to the specific cuts named. Mixed packages often include other proteins, such as chicken, pork, seafood, sides and desserts, which are not part of the beef tenderness program.
Where can you buy certified tender Omaha Steaks?
The main place is omahasteaks.com. In September 2026 Omaha Steaks said it had cut its average delivery time from more than six days in early 2025 to two days, with same-day and next-day delivery reaching more customers through an expanding retail and fulfillment network. It also says its beef is 100% U.S.-sourced and hand-cut in Omaha.
Omaha Steaks has sold through Target Plus, Target's third-party marketplace, since November 2025. The initial assortment included packages with USDA Certified Tender steaks.
If you are buying steaks as a gift this season, our guide to choosing holiday food gifts and timing delivery covers ordering windows. Our news report on Omaha Steaks' 2026 holiday gifting and delivery dates has the brand's own holiday timing and rewards details.
Quick answers
- Is Certified Tender the same as Prime? No. Prime is a quality grade based mostly on marbling. Certified Tender is based on measured tenderness.
- What is the difference between Tender and Very Tender? Very Tender is the stricter level. Omaha Steaks' filet mignons carry it.
- Which Omaha Steaks cuts are Certified Tender? Ribeyes, New York Strips, Top Sirloins, T-Bones, Porterhouse steaks and the Top Sirloin Filet. The filet mignons are Certified Very Tender.
- Who does the testing? Omaha Steaks says the steaks go through third-party shear-force testing at a USDA-certified lab before USDA approval.
References
- USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, "Beef Grades: Shields and Marbling Pictures" (USDA Certified Tender or Very Tender). https://www.ams.usda.gov/grades-standards/beef/shields-and-marbling-pictures
- Omaha Steaks, "Omaha Steaks Filet Mignons Honored With Rare and Prestigious USDA Certified Tender Designation," PR Newswire, September 18, 2024. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/omaha-steaks-filet-mignons-honored-with-rare-and-prestigious-usda-certified-tender-designation-302251195.html
- Omaha Steaks, "Omaha Steaks Earns More Prestigious USDA Certified Tender and Very Tender Designations Across Expanded Steak Lineup," PR Newswire, August 5, 2025. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/omaha-steaks-earns-more-prestigious-usda-certified-tender-and-very-tender-designations-across-expanded-steak-lineup-302522038.html
- Omaha Steaks, "Omaha Steaks Introduces First-Ever USDA Certified Tender Top Sirloin Filet," PR Newswire, April 2026. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/omaha-steaks-introduces-first-ever-usda-certified-tender-top-sirloin-filet-302735969.html
- Omaha Steaks, "Omaha Steaks Unveils Business Transformation and New 'No Bull' Brand Platform," PR Newswire, September 10, 2026. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/omaha-steaks-unveils-business-transformation-and-new-no-bull-brand-platform-doubling-down-on-value-and-transparency-302874181.html
- Omaha Steaks, "Omaha Steaks Launches on Target Plus to Bring Premium Offerings to Guests," PR Newswire, November 18, 2025. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/omaha-steaks-launches-on-target-plus-to-bring-premium-offerings-to-guests-302618385.html
- USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service, "Safe Minimum Internal Temperature Chart." https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-and-preparation/food-safety-basics/safe-temperature-chart
Meet your guide
Lipeiguan
author